January 21, 2025
Receiving an unfavorable ruling in a family law case due to error can be both frustrating and deeply concerning, especially when it affects you and your loved ones. However, there is still hope—filing a family law appeal provides an opportunity to challenge and potentially correct the trial court’s decision.
The Bellinger Law Office has been helping frustrated families like yours navigate the appellate process in Indiana for nearly 20 years and wants to see you succeed. In this post, we’ll break down Indiana’s appellate process, explain when and how a family law ruling can be appealed, and provide tips to strengthen your case.
A family law appeal is a legal process where a higher court reviews the decision of a lower court to determine if there were errors in the application of the law or procedural missteps. It’s important to note that an appeal is not a retrial; it focuses solely on whether the legal proceedings and final decision were handled properly.
When filing an appeal, your goal is to convince the appellate judges that the trial court made a mistake that warrants a reversal or modification of its ruling. Whether your case involves a child custody dispute, spousal support, or property division, appeals provide a way to seek a fair resolution.
It’s important to note, though, that not all unfavorable rulings qualify for appeal. An appeal may be filed only if legal mistakes were made during your case. For example:
An appeal is not designed to reexamine facts but to correct legal errors, so make sure you consult an experienced attorney to evaluate your case.
After filing the Notice of Appeal, the trial court clerk has 30 days to compile and submit the clerk’s record to the appellate court. Additionally, a transcript of the trial must be prepared. It’s critical to ensure all paperwork is accurate and complete.
The appellate record includes everything submitted during the trial, including pleadings, evidence, motions, and the final judgment. This record is the foundation of your appeal, as appellate judges base their decisions solely on these materials.
Once the record is complete, both parties submit written briefs to outline their arguments. The appellant (you) will submit the Appellant’s Brief, highlighting the errors made by the trial court and explaining why the decision should be revised.
The appellee (the opposing party) then submits a Response Brief to counter your arguments. A reply brief from the appellant may follow.
On occasion, the court may schedule oral arguments to allow each side’s attorney to present their case in person and answer questions from the judges.
After reviewing the record, briefs, and oral arguments, three appellate judges deliberate to reach a decision. Their outcome can take one of the following forms:
The judges’ decision is typically accompanied by a written opinion outlining their reasoning.
Appeals involve legal complexities, strict deadlines, and high attention to detail. An experienced appellate attorney is essential to present your case effectively and increase your chances of success.
It’s easy to feel emotional after a disappointing trial outcome, but appeals focus solely on legal arguments. Clearly identify errors, such as improper use of evidence or misinterpretation of laws, and build a case around these points.
A compelling brief is the most important element of your appeal. Work with your attorney to craft a clear, well-organized document supported by legal precedents and persuasive arguments.
Missed deadlines can derail your appeal from the start. Keep track of crucial dates, such as the deadline to file your Notice of Appeal, submit the record, and file briefs.
Not all appeals succeed. While a well-prepared appeal can lead to justice, it’s important to understand the limitations of the appellate process.
Appeals play a significant role in ensuring fairness and accountability within the justice system. For families, they offer a critical opportunity to correct errors that may impact custody, support, or financial security. The process can seem daunting, but with the right legal guidance, it’s a powerful tool to protect your rights and the well-being of your loved ones.
If you’re considering a family law appeal, don’t do it alone. Contact The Bellinger Law Office today for skilled legal advice and representation. Our team is here to guide you every step of the way.
Receiving an unfavorable ruling in a family law case due to error can be both frustrating and deeply concerning, especially when it affects you and your loved ones. However, there…
Life is full of changes—some exciting, some challenging. Whether you're preparing to join your life with someone in marriage or navigating the end of a relationship through divorce, there are…
Grandparents often play a vital role in a child's life, providing love, guidance, and stability that can act as an anchor during challenging times. But when family dynamics shift due…